Tesseract wrote:Christianity and some other religions both promote the idea that life on earth is meaningful for what you will get in the next world.
I find that many Christians view the idea that good works will get you to heaven as offensive and incorrect.
Yes, you're right, Tesseract. The idea that good works get you to Heaven
is incorrect -- the Bible even says so. It says that we are saved by Grace through Faith, and not by Works. The works are our way of serving God because we want to serve Him, and a way of helping others. But they are not what gets us to Heaven.
Modern scientific advances such as plumbing, crop rotation and countless other things have allowed us to get an increasingly large percentage of the human population to have access to basic life needs, such as food and water. People are generally a lot happier when they don't have to constantly worry about where their next meal will come from.
That's very true. Science is a wonderful thing.
I believe in Science, and I believe it is very useful and helpful and beneficial. I'm also a Christian. I believe God created Science. And I see nothing about my religion that shows Science as something incorrect or unhelpful. I also see nothing about my religion that hinders Science. I've never seen a case where the beliefs of a true Christian got in the way of real Scientific discoveries. I've heard of cases, of course, long ago where superstitious people, and "ceremonial religious" people let their beliefs (Which were based more on ignorance than God's Word) get in the way of Scientific discoveries. But they don't believe the same things a true Christian believes. A true Christian believes that God created Science, and that there are many things about the earth and universe we have yet to discover.
The main difference I've seen between Christian scientists and secular Scientists is their theory as to how the world began. And that doesn't affect every branch of Science. And when it does affect a certain branch, I've heard both positive and negative things about both results -- how the Christian scientists did this good thing because of the creation theory, how they did this bad thing because of the creation theory. How secular Scientists did this good thing because they believe in Evolution, and how they did this bad thing because of their belief in Evolution. There are also Christian Scientists who believe in Evolution. So it seems to me there's been mixed results in both divisions. And that just shows, to me personally, that God uses all sorts of different things for different purposes. He used this person's belief, and that person's disbelief, in order for us all to learn something new in some way.
Interestingly enough, C. S. Lewis was actually an atheist for a while because of the reality and loss in his life.
He also changed his mind about this. And not because the pain had lessened over time, either. In fact, I remember reading a part where he said that there wasn't one moment in any part of his life where the memory of those deaths did not give him terrible pain. So he still had that with him when he decided to become a Christian. The pain did not seem to him like a reason he should avoid or disbelieve Christianity. In fact, his witnessing of loss and death and pain came in handy to achieve a very great purpose. It inspired him to think about pain and loss, and write about them in books like
The Problem of Pain and
A Grief Observed -- books that have helped a lot of people in many great ways. Which is an example of how God uses death, pain, trials, and everything else "bad" to accomplish something even better than we could imagine.
"Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." Because we are selfish, fallen pigs. Old Wisdom from folks who realized a thing or two about the human race. Not first realized by modern philosophers. Goes way back even before Jesus.
I guess the question, then, is did we need religion to tell us this? I don't think so.
We don't need religion to tell us we're fallen pigs. (Although, haha, I have met a few people who might need something to help them realize it. They still think humans are basically good.
) But just because we don't need religion to tell us
this, that doesn't mean we don't need religion
at all. The point is,
if we are fallen pigs, what do we do about it? This is an especially important question to those who believe -- or are considering in believing -- in an afterlife. After all, if only the perfect are allowed into heaven, and we're all imperfect pigs, how do we get there to avoid Hell?
That's where religion comes in handy.
So, I guess the real question would be, do you/should you believe in an afterlife? Which I discuss after the next quote...
I don't think it's wise for someone from our world to believe, for example, that Narnia exists. It may make them feel happy, but they're going to be disappointed every time they walk into a wardrobe with high hopes. If one is trying to get somewhere such as utopian afterlife, they will never feel complete because they will spend their whole life expecting something, and never actually experience it. They will never get that moment of final satisfaction in reaching the place that they are trying to get to.
First off, I don't believe Narnia exists (of course), but I do believe in Heaven. And I don't see why it's a bad thing to believe, because --
1. If it does exist, I'll be there, enjoying it.
2. If it doesn't exist -- if there is no afterlife, and we just cease to exist when we die, then I won't be able to be disappointed. I won't exist anymore. A non-existant thing can't have feelings, and therefore cannot have the feeling of disapointment.
Whereas, if I choose not to believe in Heaven, it will also go one of two ways --
1. I turn out to be wrong, there is a Heaven, but I can't go there because I didn't believe. And then I end up going... the
other way.
OR
2. I spend my life believing there is no hope beyond this world, then I die, and I am no more.
Some people say that it's better to believe there is no afterlife, because then you'll live this life on earth to the fullest, and make the most use of your time, instead of wasting your life pining for Heaven. But that isn't the case -- at least, it isn't for me. I believe in Heaven and God. But I'm certainly not just sitting around waiting for heaven to come. I am already living life to the fullest -- using all the time I have to help people in any way I can, so that I can please God, and make the lives of others better too because I care about them. My religion is making me do more, not less. A disbelief in an afterlife wouldn't make me live life any fuller, because I am already doing all I can to live to my fullest. If I turn out to be right, I will be rewarded in Heaven. If I turn out to be wrong, then I have made good use of my life, I lose nothing, and I won't be disappointed because I wouldn't exist anymore in order to
be disappointed.
~Riella