ericnovak, Sure Disney started a stupid romance that shouldn't have been there, but they did end it as well! It's just that kiss needed to be taken out most of all! I agree as well that Fox should not have added that line with Caspian saying "none could compare with your sister." but it's there so that they could give Suspian fans something to awe at.
I don't agree with how you said he's still in love with her just by the way her bow and horn is displayed in his room. So is Peter's and Lucy's belongings, they are displayed in his room as well. As are many pictures of the Pevensie's instead of Susan. For all we know Lucy could have been on the other side of the door. Perhaps the green mist got to Caspian as well and got him to temp for Susan for all these years! Never know.
I will admit I loved what I saw between Caspian and Lilliandil. They were neutral and natural. That's the way you should start a relationship. Caspian and Susan were obsessive and rushed. That's not how love starts and it's not love to begin with. It's called spontaneous infatuation and not many romances last that way because there could have been problems down the road.
Lets say if Susan really did stay in Narnia and Caspian got to see the other side of her that turns her against Aslan, he didn't really like it or the the typical fights every normal relationship will have but would do anything to be with her just because she was beautiful. Sounds very shallow and selfish, just like Rabadash, there's no difference in these men who fall for Susan's beauty. And no I don't consider Caspian/Susan romantic, because their relationship was more underdeveloped than what Caspian/Lilliandil's relationship will become.
Susan could have been the type to not marry early or some what later in her relationship with Caspian. I bet she would have thrown a ball to see if she was compatible with someone else or went behind Caspian's back. I'm not trying to offend any fans of Susan and Suspian, but that's what Susan is, she desires beauty more then Lucy does and she craves the attention (why do you think Lucy didn't enjoy that vision so much from the attention?). Somehow and someway if Susan was in Narnia Caspian and Lilliandil will have gotten together, true love always finds a way.
Like i said it was obviously the green mist that tempted Caspian in the first place. I mean lust is a temptation after all.
The only thing that really bothered me in the film between Caspian and Lilliandil was right after Caspian left and I agree with most of you on this one that Caspian should have mentioned going back to Ramandu island to see Lilliandil again. Us book fans know that he'll go back, and he said "I hope we meet again", but non book fans will not know if she was good or bad unless they go ahead and read the books to find out. They should have shown or had Caspian say something in the film to indicate her existance somehow.
The only thing we can do is make a thread about that and a petiton for more in SC or for an extened edition of VDT with more Caspian/Lilliandil scenes.