Eating vs. Killing

The cultures, creatures, geography — anything about the books!

Moderators: DiGoRyKiRkE, Varnafinde

Eating vs. Killing

Postby L.M. Pevensie » Oct 17, 2009 5:48 pm

I've been tutoring a couple of elementary children in public speaking class. One of my students told us the story of LWW as his assignment this week. He said that Aslan "ate the White Witch". :-\ Before I could help it the children broke out into a huge argument about whether Aslan eats people (especially witches) or if he just kills them. I admit the former does not provide a very nice picture. /:)

I wouldn't think eating, but one of the children said that in the BBC Silver Chair movie Aslan said that he did, is that true? I've never seen them and I don't know if this 8 year old is the best authority of the subject. :)

I've never thought about this, and I doubt it's very important. I don't mean to gross anyone out, but I thought I'd pose the question for the sake of my students: Does Aslan kill and eat or just kill? What do you think????
Image

If this Sig is by you please let me know, because I can't remember :-(

"I am going to live forever, or die trying!"
User avatar
L.M. Pevensie
NarniaWeb Nut
 
Posts: 186
Joined: Jul 27, 2009
Location: Midwest

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby ClvrEttinsmoorGiant » Oct 17, 2009 6:22 pm

Well in SC it says that he has "swallowed" up girls, boys, kings, etc. I don't know if that implies that he ate them. But, I would tend to go towards Eating. Maybe you should do a poll on it.
Where there are two Narnia Webbers there are three opinions.
User avatar
ClvrEttinsmoorGiant
NarniaWeb Regular
 
Posts: 33
Joined: Jun 08, 2009
Location: Western Wild
Gender: Female

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby daughter of the King » Oct 17, 2009 8:25 pm

I don't think he means swallowed in the literal sense. Not physically, anyway. He didn't eat girls, at least, not in the way Jill meant. It's a metaphor. He "swallows" people and creatures in the way that he changes them. The best examples I can think of are Edmund and Eustace. Aslan does not eat either of them, but he swallows up their old selves and leaves them new. That probably didn't make any sense. But no, I do not think Aslan actually eats people!
Image
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal
User avatar
daughter of the King
Moderator
Princess Dot
 
Posts: 2564
Joined: Sep 22, 2009
Gender: Female

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby jadis of narnia » Oct 19, 2009 8:30 am

I doubt Aslan "eats" them afterwards, if he does kill them..

Reading from the SC book, the coversation says:

Jill: will you promise not to - do anything to me, if I come?
Aslan: I make no promise..
Jill: do you eat girls?
Aslan: I have swallowed up girls, boys, women and men, kings and emperors, cities, and realms..

So, yeah, I don't think it was in a literal sense, either.. maybe he swallowed each one of them up in different ways.. in either good or bad ways.. and no, I don't believe he ate the witch.. he seems too noble for that.. he just killed her.. and perhaps stored her body away where no one could find it ever again..

maybe.. :/
jadis of narnia
 

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby Valiant_Lucy » Oct 19, 2009 12:22 pm

I agree with everyone else in that I don't think it's completely literal.

jadis of narnia wrote:and perhaps stored her body away where no one could find it ever again..

I like how you put it, jadis of narnia. To actually imagine Aslan eating or brutally killing someone seems a bit out of character for him. Maybe when he "swallows" them, he kind of...I don't know...breathes on them, and they disappear? Die?

Very good questions though! :)
"Imperfection is beauty, madness is genius, and it's better to be absolutely ridiculous than absolutely boring." Marilyn Monroe
User avatar
Valiant_Lucy
Moderator Emeritus
The IMAR&NB mod
 
Posts: 9142
Joined: Jan 13, 2006
Location: Canada
Gender: Female

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby Pattertwigs Pal » Oct 19, 2009 6:00 pm

Well, I have always taken the part in SC literally. But, I read the section to my mom and my sister and they looked at me like I was nuts for taking it literally. Now, I'm not sure what to think. :-\ I didn't think of it as eating exactly in the sense that he killed a person and then made a meal of them as any lion would, but more in the sense that he swallowed them whole. A couple things I am almost positive about:
  1. Jill took it literally.
  2. He only kills / swallows people or creatures who deserve it.
  3. He isn't a tame lion (I almost hate saying that with the negative feel it gets from LB :p But taken with the above point it isn't so bad.)

I don't remember exactly what the line is in the BBC's SC :ymblushing: but I think it probably uses the word swallow and not "eat." I'll pop the DVD in if I get a chance.
Image
Silver Chair Reading Group
NW sister to Movie Aristotle & daughter of the King
User avatar
Pattertwigs Pal
Moderator
Cookie Queen of NarniaWeb
 
Posts: 5212
Joined: May 16, 2009
Location: U.S.A.
Gender: Female

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby jadis of narnia » Oct 20, 2009 6:42 am

Actually, now that I think about it.. if Aslan was able to make all the characters vanish from one world and reappear in another in a matter of a second.. that could also be, in a way, swallowing them up.. it would seem so to me.. and we know he's able to create and end(or swallow up) worlds..

as well as completely changing them and helping the characters (most of them) to accept him as their friend/king.. :/
jadis of narnia
 

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby ChristProclamer » Oct 28, 2009 9:19 pm

I think He could eat them. I mean, I don't honestly see anything wrong with Aslan eating people. Not to keep himself fed or anything, but simply to be rid of them. That sounds awful, but when you think about it there really isn't anything wrong with it.
However, I do not believe that Aslan ate the White Witch in this particular instance. The book just says he "flung himself upon her" and they "rolled over together but with the Witch underneath" and then leaves it there, going on to describe the rest of the battle. That may be an irrelivant point though, if we're only talking about the BBC versions...
And I don't remember Aslan eating anyone in Silver Chair...
Image
User avatar
ChristProclamer
NarniaWeb Guru
 
Posts: 1169
Joined: Sep 18, 2007
Location: I'm on my computer, dear.

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby RevelinginWonder » Oct 30, 2009 9:22 pm

No, I don't think Aslan eats them in the literal sense. I agree with daughter of the King. I think that he swallows their old selves. I don't think that Aslan ate the White Witch. Yes, that's all I have to say, and it has already been said, but this is my opinion. ;) :D
Image

Thank you to Djaq for the marvelous signature!

NWeb siblings: pogginfan and Windsong!
User avatar
RevelinginWonder
NarniaWeb Nut
 
Posts: 107
Joined: Jun 23, 2009
Gender: Female

Re: Eating vs. Killing

Postby polly plummer » Oct 31, 2009 2:51 pm

I don't think Aslan ate anyone literally either, but you can see it from an elementary school kids point of view - they take everything so literally =))

PS love that quote from Edmund from PC movie 'I know you had it sorted' - it's so cool
polly plummer
NarniaWeb Regular
 
Posts: 82
Joined: Oct 18, 2009
Gender: Female


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest