NarniaWeb Community Forums

Very close between Edmund and Caspian, but I finally picked Caspian. His faith in the Old Narnians finally being proven true is great. But I liked him best in VDT, where he kept getting into arguments about gold and running off to the end of the world and stuff like that; so Aslan has to appear to make him stop being such a spoiled brat. It made him seem more real--sure, he's the great king, but he makes mistakes too.

I voted for Peter because I like his character so much. He really cares for his siblings so much. I like the scene in LWW where he was trying to cheer up Lucy and he was sorry (to Lucy) for not believing her. *sigh* He's a very good brother, a very very good one.

I like Edmund, because his transformation is so exciting. And then he was pretty epic in PC.

Only four votes for Digory? I like him because, even though he freed Jadis, (What on Earth/Charn were you thinking?!?) he did what was possible to fix his mistakes. Way to go Dig!

I like him, especially when he's grown up. He has one of the best lines

What do they teach them at these schools?

I'm not sure... I can't vote. I think Edmund, Peter, Eustace and Digory all have some great pluses. Ed and Peter are definately high up there. Ed probably is just beyond Peter. Eustace definately more a favourite than Peter, perhaps even beats Ed. I'm not sure. It's almost a draw between Ed and Eustace. And Peter's just about there. I think it would have been easier to choose, and I think I would have said 'Peter! hands down' if he had a much better attitude in the movie adaption of PC. Something about him being High King above all the rest makes him noble and glorious.

Of the Narnian born kings, I'd definately say Tirian!

Boy Scout wrote:Only four votes for Digory? I like him because, even though he freed Jadis, (What on Earth/Charn were you thinking?!?) he did what was possible to fix his mistakes. Way to go Dig!

Yeah! Way to go Digory! I like his character too, he was a gentleman too to his mother and Polly. I loved him the most when he was in the situation of temptation because of the witch in the garden in MN, good thing he still believed in Aslan, three cheers for Digory!!

In the movies, Peter is my favorite character. Yes, I like movie Peter. His character is given a bit more depth and a better character arc. I agreed with him in almost all of the decisions he made (and and furious at Caspian for screwing up the night raid). He didnt have that bad of an attitude. Yeah the train fight wasnt needed, but almost every guy gets in a fight sometime when they just could have let the problem go. Its just human. Peter also felt responsible, even though it wasnt his fault, for the trouble Narnia was in and everything he did was to try to make things right.

I also liked him in LWW (books and films) for just being a good leader and trying to be a good brother to Edmund.

In the books though, I would have to say Tirian. He's just cool.

Wow a lot of people did Edmund! I wish we could have one of these things for the girls too! I picked Caspian because I love his character all around, he can be pretty bad at times but at other times he is pretty good too! I can understand why a lot of people picked Edmund, how he betrayed them and then changed so much. But anyway, I like Caspian the best!

LuvNarnia, we do have a thread for the girls. Here is a link:

Click Here

My vote is for Eustace. He seems to me to be the character with the most depth in the series. He was so hilarious before he was changed, back in the beginning of Dawn Treader. Then, the experience that changed him was one of the best parts of that book. And after he was changed, he seemed to me to be the nicest of all the characters. I loved his patience with Jill Pole, and his slow change from a coward and a brat to a Christian and a hero.

Caspian b/c hes brave and puts his crew/people before hime (most of the time). Although Peter and Edmund are close seconds....

I really like them all, but I chose Eustace, because he's an annoying little person, who changes into a better person, although he can still be a pain in the neck. It's such an emotional and spiritual scene when he lets Aslan take his scales off when he was a dragon. What a great way to show redemption!

I'd almost pick Peter or Edmund, because I LOVE their characters in the books and I love them in the Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. But I'm not impressed with their characters in PC . But I picked Caspian because I have ALWAYS been impressed and pleased with his character, even in the movies (dispute the whole Susan thing ). So I like Caspian best .

I said Peter but I like both Peter and Edmund

Peter and Edmund have their own characteristics so it really was hard for me to choose between them.

PS: Welcome to NW AnnaStar! I think I haven't seen you much here but anyways, feel free to message me!