DiGoRyKiRkE wrote:This claim seems to be in direct opposition to Lewis' logic and principles. By making this claim, you're making the claim that looks are more important than principles.
Whoa, whoa, wait a minute. Where did I say looks are
more important than principles? As far as I know, I didn't. It wouldn't make much sense for me to say something like that either, since it's not something I believe, and I know it's something that C.S. Lewis didn't believe. Principles, of
course, are more important than looks.
The only point I'm making is that the outward appearance of some of the characters could be something the author chose to use as an outward sign of an inward quality. A reflection on the outside, of something that is on the inside. It wouldn't be the first time it's been used in literature. A lot of authors will give their villains "villinous appearances" such as hook noses, yellowy eyes, etc; just as they'll give the heroes certain looks. I've seen books where all the good characters had blond hair, and all the villains had red hair, or black hair. Not that the author is saying people in
real life are villainous if they have those hair colors or appearances. it's just a thing that happens in the story, and the story alone. And I know C.S. Lewis for sure used it in other parts -- he made his good heroes fair-skinned and light-haired for the most part, and the evil Calormenes to have dark skin and hair. Not that I'm saying C.S. Lewis was prejudice, because I don't believe he was. But as I said, authors do sometimes choose a certain look for the villains, and a certain look for the heroes.
And I stand by my theory that the good dwarves have a slightly odd look, whereas the bad ones have a slightly more human look. That's what it sounds like the Beavers are saying when I read that passage. I'm not saying "Oh yeah, I'm totally 100% right, and everyone better agree with me, so there!" or anything. It's just my opinion. It's just something that I found interesting, so I thought I would share it with all of you, in case you guys found it interesting too.
And
Greymouser, you're right -- the bad dwarves don't look completely human, but the point is they look
more human than the good dwarves do. Compare a picture of Trumpkin with a picture of Nikabrik or the Witch's dwarf. You can see a definite difference there.
And although not all of the illustrations will look 100% like the things in the book, C.S. Lewis
did say, when he saw the illustrations, that it all looked just as he pictured it. And the original illustrations he saw were in black and white, so it's very hard to tell from those what someone's hair color is. Although, Lucy's hair actually looked blond to me -- especially in the picture of her in PC, Chapter 2, when they're in the Treasure House.
~Riella