Gilby's Angel wrote:From the beginning of the movie, it was made clear that Peter's real conflict was with Aslan, not Caspian. That's why when Peter gives Caspian his sword, Peter's character arc isn't truly complete. We never get to see Peter resolve his 'Aslan dilemma' so, at the end of the movie, we're left with that feeling of wanting more.
Excellent point. I know a lot of people thought Peter's attitude in the movie made him more realistic and approachable than his character in the book, but I couldn't stand Peter. I found his attitude dreadfully tiresome and I think I would have liked him more if his quarrel with Aslan had been resolved. The first thing Peter says to Aslan in the book is "I'm sorry." Movie!Peter never had such a moment.
Gilby's Angel wrote: From the attempted murder of Caspian at the opening through to the end of the Night Raid, part of what makes you care about the characters is the darkness each is facing. Lighten the mood and you negatively impact the emotional involvement you feel.
I disagree. The only character I felt any emotional involvement with was Lucy. I think the audience should have been given a little bit more time to know Caspian before jumping right into him running away. I felt more angry at Peter after the Night Raid then sadness for the Narnians who died.
fantasia_kitty wrote:There is no moment where you read about the emotional loss of life like where you see Glenstorm nod farewell to his son who is about to die. No mention of carnage strewn about on the battlefield. In fact, Lewis brings some humor into the situation by talking about Wimbleweather's tears splashing on the mice (at least, I thought it was funny ).
You're not the only one. I think that's the key for why a lot of people think PC was too dark. Yes, Narnians die in the book, but it's glossed over. Much like the battle in Book!LWW is mostly told through flashback. That's not the important part of the story. The emotional journey of the characters is what is important, and that is heavily glossed over in the film. Neither Peter's nor Susan's arcs really felt complete, Edmund got very little development at all, and I wasn't given enough time to like Caspian to appreciate the end of his arc.
As for the romp, I really wish it had been kept in. It shows that restoring Narnia wasn't just about winning the war. The Telmarine people had to be freed from Miraz's rule just as much as the Narnians. As for it being a bit bizarre in the book, well, this is Bacchus and Silenus we're talking about. It could have been a lot more bizarre quite easily.