April Fools: Who's Who of HobbitWeb!

[starkat]

When I went into the chatroom behind my parents back, I saw that there was some guessing going on about who used to be who from that other website NarniaWeb. Here is a place for you to post your guesses!

[wolfloversk]

SHOW SPOILER

Eye of Sauron= FK
Samwise Gamgee= Jo
Boern= Digs
Daisy Gamgee= starkat
Gundabald Bolger= Ramagut
Elanor Gamgee= stargazer
Bard the Bowman= GlimGlum
Kili= Djaq
The Eleventh Doctor= Lady Arwen
Lady Arwen= not sure... but it isn't Lady Arwen
Random Hobbit= flambeau
Gimilifan15= Gymfan?
Rosie Cotton= P's Pal
Fili=Mountie
Bilbo= coracle

Edited x3

[Aslanisthebest]

Haha, here goes!

SHOW SPOILER

Daisy Gamgee - starkat
Samwise Gamgee - johobbit
Rosie Cotton - Patterwigs Pal
Beorn - DiGoRyKiRke
Gimlifan15 - Gymfan 15
Elanor Gamgee - stargazer
The Eye of Sauron - Fantasia Kitty
Hugo Bracegirdle - Meltintalle
Gundabald Bolger - ramagut
Legolas Greenleaf - PrinceCor004
Goldberry/The Eleventh Doctor/The White Queen - Lady Arwen
Bilbo - coracle
Bard the Bowman - GlimGlum
Random Hobbit - flambeau
Fili - MountainFireFlower
Kili - Djaq
Lady Arwen - daughter of the King
Aragorn - Malkah
Galadriel - Gwendolen
Pippin Took - Princess Anna
Goldberrys Wittle Cupcake/River Song - Bookwyrm

I ended up seeing two when the profiles were in the process of being changed, so those I didn't completely figure out. However, after seeing that Fili was Mountie, I did somehow guess that Kili would be Djaq when Djaq would change hers.
I have no idea who the other duplicate accounts are, like Katniss Everdeen, Gale Hawthorne, Justin Beiber, SithLady, etc are but I have vague guesses.

Edited to update one once.

[Ithilwen]

SHOW SPOILER

The Eye of Sauron: Fantasia Kitty
Aragorn: Malkah
Bard the Bowman: Glimglum
Beorn: DiGoRy KiRkE
Bilbo: Coracle
Daisy Gamgee: starkat
Eleanor Gamgee: stargazer
Fili: Mountie
Galadriel: Gwendolyn
Gimilifan15: Gymfan15
Gundabold Bolger: Ramagut
Hugo Bracegirdle: Meltintalle
Kili: Djaq
Lady Arwen: Daughter of the King
Legolas Greenleaf/The Dark Knight: Prince Cor
Pippin Took: Princess Anna
Random Hobbit: Flambeau
River Song/Wittle Cupcake: Bookwyrm
Rosie Cotton: Pattertwig's Pal
Samwise Gamgee: Johobbit
The Eleventh Doctor/Goldberry: Lady Arwen

~Riella

[Gale Hawthorne]

I have no idea who the other duplicate accounts are, like Katniss Everdeen, Gale Hawthorne, Justin Beiber, SithLady, etc are but I have vague guesses.

This is ridiculous! Does no one know who I am? Just because I'm not Peeta doesn't mean I'm less awesome. >.>

[wolfloversk]

I have no idea who the other duplicate accounts are, like Katniss Everdeen, Gale Hawthorne, Justin Beiber, SithLady, etc are but I have vague guesses.

This is ridiculous! Does no one know who I am? Just because I'm not Peeta doesn't mean I'm less awesome. >.>

I'm suspecting 12, nn, Mino, gf1, and Booky may be behind some, but I'm not positive... I can say for a fact however it's not ...the wolf

Edit The White Queen is back...

Edit 2 or Ithy... could be Ithy.

[Aslanisthebest]

Who said anything about Peeta...?

Wolf, ditto -- I'm also sure that The Rose-Tree Dryad is behind some of them, too.
Barney... this is random, but I'm guessing The Gentle Warrior.

[wolfloversk]

And Libby... could be Libby... Awwe lets face it could be anyone

-Gremlin Detective

[Gale Hawthorne]

Who said anything about Peeta...?

Oh, no one except the whole world. Everyone loves him. >.> The boy with the bread is so popular. I would think Catnip's best friend deserves a little credit at least once in a while. And even Katniss has forsaken me today...

[Weirdo]

Well, Gale gets plenty of credit. Everyone likes Peeta, because Peeta is sweet. But I believe Gale is cool because he's a lot like Katniss.
If we all like Katniss and Gale is like Katniss, shouldn't we like Gale too? I believe we do; if it's any comfort.
(I do at least)

[Ithilwen]

Welll... I might have a few guesses about certain people.

SHOW SPOILER

Sith Lady = Bookwyrm
Barney = TheGentleWarrior
Gale Hawethorn = Mountie?? (Shadowlander was another guess)
Dori = either Weir or Gil. Most likely Weir
Amy Pond = possibly Cor
Rory = Not entirely sure. It could be Ryan, Cor, or even Mountie.
Eustace Clarence = Malkah

[Miss Rosario]

I know several of the mods switched their names around several times, and I haven't been on much today to update the list.... But here's yesterday's list:

Jo – Samwise Gamgee
Lady Arwen – Goldberry/The Eleventh Doctor/The White Queen (I think)
Mountie – Fili
Cor – Legolas Greenleaf/The Dark Knight
Ramagut – Gundabald Bolger
Pattertwig’s Pal – Rosie Cotton
Malkah – Aragorn
DiGs – Beorn
Stargazer – Elanor Gamgee
Fantasia – The Eye of Sauron
Meltintalle – Hugo Bracegirdle
Djaq – Kili
Daughter of the King – Lady Arwen
Coracle – Bilbo
Gymfan15 – Gimilifan15
Flambeau – Random Hobbit
GlimGlum – Bard the Bowman
Starkat – Daisy Gamgee
Gwendolen – Galadriel
Princess Anna – Pippin Took
Booky - River Song

I have not figured out the mods who aren't on the mod list. As Bella mentioned above me, there are quite a few members I have questions about. Either mods are masquerading as members, or else other members are doing it. Or both. Who's to say?

[Gale Hawthorne]

Well, Gale gets plenty of credit. Everyone likes Peeta, because Peeta is sweet. But I believe Gale is cool because he's a lot like Katniss.
If we all like Katniss and Gale is like Katniss, shouldn't we like Gale too? I believe we do; if it's any comfort.
(I do at least)

Thank you, Dori. You're such a great friend. Now would you like some more marshmallows? Or Dr. Pepper? Or ginger ale?

P.S., Thank you for untying me earlier.

[Weirdo]

Hm...Dr Pepper, please. And you're a great friend too.

P.S., You're very welcome.

[Rory]

I think this thread is rubbish. Who would I be except myself?

Oh, and for the record, I still haven't found Amy.

[Ithilwen]

I think this thread is rubbish. Who would I be except myself?

Oh, and for the record, I still haven't found Amy.

STILL?! I wonder if the Weeping Angels got her... I hear they've been spotted in the area. I haven't found Rose Tyler either.