Good question!
Personally, I've always loved Lucy's the best. It's so simple yet elegant (as
beloved said), and I would love to wear it.
My second choice would be Susan's crown. Susan's makes me think of autumn, where as Lucy's makes me think of spring.
As for the kings, like you
narnialover4 I've always liked silver better. So, I'd probably say I like Edmund's the best out of the two. But Peter's is very impressive and "High-Kingly." I think that they did an
awesome job with all the crowns... they're all so perfect.
Daughter_of_Ramandu, I've never seen the BBC version crowns!
Are there pictures anywhere I could look at?