This forum has been archived. Please visit the new forum at https://community.narniaweb.com/

Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

C. S. Lewis, his worlds, and his faith.

Moderators: coracle, Lady Arwen

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby 220chrisTian » Feb 24, 2010 3:33 pm

I'm sorry for not contributing to this discussion much lately. Part of the reason is that I haven't read the book in many, many years. :(

@Liberty: I like the comparison you made between Aslan's signs and the Bible. We have to remember and do them. :) Otherwise, we'll get lost. :(

@Pattertwig: I disagree about us not having "solid proof" for Christianity. We have creation, the Bible, the recorded death and resurrection of Christ, and changed lives as a result of believing the first three [i.e. God's self-revelation and sacrifice]. :) I like what you said about fear. It's not fear vs faith. It's having the right kind of fear that counts, for it will produce courage and obedience. :)

I found an article today in which the author interviews [Feb 23] Billy Graham on his life and ministry. Here's an excerpt.
Is there one temptation you've struggled with throughout your lifetime -- one you find yourself confessing to God over and over?

Ruth and our children used to kid me about being a pessimist, and worrying too much about some situation we might be facing. Sometimes they even called me "Puddleglum", after one of C. S. Lewis' imaginary characters in The Chronicles of Narnia who tended to be a pessimist. But their comments had a serious side to them, because they were reminding me that I wasn't trusting God the way I should. Once we understand that God loves us, we can commit the future into His hands and quit worrying about it all the time.

What are your thoughts on the Graham family's view of Puddleglum's pessimism, i.e. its effect on how a person lives his/her life and his/her trust in God? :)
220chrisTian
 

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby daughter of the King » Feb 24, 2010 7:55 pm

Hm.........I don't think Puddleglum is pessimistic because he doesn't trust Aslan. On the contrary, there is more than one instance where he shows complete faith in Him.

When they discover the words "UNDER ME":
No doubt, if we'd had our minds on our job when we were at the Ruinous City, we'd have been shown how--found a little door, or a cave, or a tunnel, met someone to help us. Might have been (you never know) Aslan himself. We'd have got down under those paving-stones somehow or other. Aslan's instructions always work: there are no exceptions. The House of Harfang

When Rilian says the words were not meant for them:
"Don't you mind him," said Puddleglum, "There are no accidents. Our guide is Aslan; and he was there when the giant King caused the letters to be cut, and he knew already all things that would come of them; including this. Travels Without the Sun

And of course the speech he gives after breaking the witch's spell, but I don't think I need to quote it.

I think Puddleglum is pessimistic because that's how he deals with the world. If you expect the best, you'll probably be disappointed. If you expect the worst, you'll be pleasantly surprised. Puddleglum could and did take this philosophy a little too far, but when Puddleglum refuses to tell what happened to him at the end and instead asks for news of war and the king's death etc, the Narnians say "Isn't that just like a Marshwiggle?" so he's not the only one.

220chrisTian wrote:I found an article today in which the author interviews [Feb 23] Billy Graham on his life and ministry. Here's an excerpt.

..... But their comments had a serious side to them, because they were reminding me that I wasn't trusting God the way I should. Once we understand that God loves us, we can commit the future into His hands and quit worrying about it all the time.

I understand what he's getting at. We shouldn't worry because it's all in God's hands. But I don't think that describes Puddleglum. He doesn't worry, he just makes a point of saying what could go wrong so everyone concerned can be prepared for it.
Image
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal
User avatar
daughter of the King
Moderator
Princess Dot
 
Posts: 2607
Joined: Sep 22, 2009
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby waggawerewolf27 » Feb 26, 2010 6:15 pm

No, I don't necessarily think Puddleglum is a Glum Puddle. :) After all, he says at the beginning, that the other marshwiggles said he was too fond of 'bobbance and bounce and high spirits', and that he should remember that 'life isn't all fricasseed frogs and eel pie'. If Puddleglum seems like a pessimist then I'd have been loath to have met the other marshwiggles. :D Perhaps it is all a matter of perspective how you see Puddleglum.

I think that Puddleglum was merely brought up with a healthy respect for Murphy's Law. That is to say, whatever can go wrong, will. Management specialists call this approach to life 'risk management', and if it wasn't for Puddleglum's constant presence, catering skills and guidance, Eustace and Jill would have fared much worse than they did.

I found this quote on a site, entitled Jenny's Books, where she has reviewed much the sort of books I like to read.

when I went and woke up my parents with nightmares, they would tell me that Aslan would blow my bad dreams away. You know, like he blew away Eustace and Jill in The Silver Chair, most terrifying Narnia book ever; and that’s what I would imagine when I was falling back asleep.


Now this is a way to explain the Silver Chair I'd never thought of before. Would you consider that Silver Chair was really the most terrifying of all the Narnia books? And exactly what about it makes the commentator I quoted say it is such a terrifying book? Is it the fears that Jill and Eustace have to overcome? The sadness of Caspian at the loss of his son and Queen? Drinian's deep feelings of shame?

Was it the creepy Harfang? In which the honoured guests are actually prisoners, a prelude to their being done like a dinner? Or was it that dark world of LOTGK? Where the three travellers are asked to free what looks like a madman? Or was it LOTGK, herself, mesmerising and drugging the Narnian four into denying Aslan or Narnia existed?

What do you think and why?
User avatar
waggawerewolf27
NarniaWeb Zealot
 
Posts: 8781
Joined: Sep 25, 2009
Location: Oz
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Lady Galadriel » Feb 26, 2010 8:50 pm

waggawerewolf27 wrote: Now this is a way to explain the Silver Chair I'd never thought of before. Would you consider that Silver Chair was really the most terrifying of all the Narnia books? And exactly what about it makes the commentator I quoted say it is such a terrifying book? Is it the fears that Jill and Eustace have to overcome? The sadness of Caspian at the loss of his son and Queen? Drinian's deep feelings of shame?

Was it the creepy Harfang? In which the honoured guests are actually prisoners, a prelude to their being done like a dinner? Or was it that dark world of LOTGK? Where the three travellers are asked to free what looks like a madman? Or was it LOTGK, herself, mesmerising and drugging the Narnian four into denying Aslan or Narnia existed?

What do you think and why?


I think that The Last Battle is the scariest. Something about the overwhelming Calormenes fighting the few remaining Narnians in Narnia's last hours makes it very eerie and very sad. But I would say The Silver Chair could be rated as the second most terrifying/darkest. I always found the Emerald Witch to be scarier than the White Witch because of her two forms, and the fate of Ramandu's Daughter. :-??

Most importantly, I think, is that the LOTGK tried to mesmerize and drug the Narnian four into denying Aslan and Narnia. That would almost certainly be known as one of the darkest scenes in the Chronicles (Aslan's death and Narnia's end excluded). I can certainly think of many other scary scenes in the other books, but none where anyone is tempted to deny Aslan. (No, wait! There's Jewel in LB...) ;) To deny Aslan would be to deny everything they know and hold true.
User avatar
Lady Galadriel
NarniaWeb Junkie
 
Posts: 597
Joined: Oct 25, 2009
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby TheGeneral » Feb 26, 2010 10:28 pm

Pattertwigs Pal wrote:They tried to use logic and explain the world to her (the lamp like the sun, Aslan like a cat), but she always had an answer and a way to shoot down their story. We can try to convince people that Christianity is true and present reasons why it is, but in the end we have no solid proof.


I agree with you. I think that's a good example from the book and the best way to parallel it. Sometimes when I think about what I believe, I can come up with questions or 'come-backs' that I have no way of answering. How I see it then, what I believe can't be proven to be true with logic. All I can do is live my life and people can then see how it affects me. Puddleglum and the kids couldn't prove Narnia and Aslan exhisted, but when Puddleglum acted courageously by ruining the witches spell and calling to Aslan, that carried a lot more weight as proof than any logical statement.
Image
User avatar
TheGeneral
NarniaWeb Junkie
 
Posts: 566
Joined: Sep 06, 2009
Location: Playing hockey
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby coracle » Feb 27, 2010 2:44 am

perspicacity wrote:I don't think this really is Christian, though. Puddleglum is essentially saying that even if there is no God he'd rather believe the comforting lie than the harsh truth. You'd be hard pressed to find a less Christian message in the Chroncles.


I think it is a realistic picture of faith down to its bare bones. When you are in a situation where your faith is sorely tried, when you are surrounded by doubts and people who don't believe what you usually do, you get to the point where all you have left is the sort of attitude that Puddleglum expressed.
Puddleglum is great in these tight places - the 'Aslan told us what to do - but he didn't say what would happen when we did it' kind of blind loyalty. And there is a great lesson in that you can find and learn about faith and right choices in the oddest of people.
“Not all of us can choose what we give up. The things we love are taken or are never ours at all. If we’re lucky, life is defined not by what we let go, but what we let in: friendship and kind words, frailty and hope.”

From 'Call The Midwife', S9 Ep2
User avatar
coracle
Moderator
NarniaWeb's Auntie
 
Posts: 20470
Joined: Feb 10, 2004
Location: New Zealand
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby daughter of the King » Mar 10, 2010 2:13 pm

waggawerewolf27 wrote:Would you consider that Silver Chair was really the most terrifying of all the Narnia books? And exactly what about it makes the commentator I quoted say it is such a terrifying book?

No, I don't think I would. I always thought LB was more terrifying than all of the rest of the books, at least the first half. Although it does contain some terrifying moments. The book opens with Jill crying behind the gym. Right away we know something is wrong. The bullying that goes on in the school I wouldn't describe as terrifying, but certainly disturbing; Eustace falling off the cliff is scary; etc. etc. The overall tone of the book is somewhat on the darker side, for Narnia anyway. I don't think I would describe it as a dark book. The darkest moment is when LotGK is trying to enchant Rilian, Eustace, Jill, and Puddleglum. The way she so condescendingly replies each time they try to break out of the spell is creepy. I can see how someone would think SC is terrifying, but I find LB more terrifying because of the way the Calormenes take over almost without Tirian even realizing what is happening. Rishda is creepy in the way he manipulates Shift, and Tash is simply frightening.
Image
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal
User avatar
daughter of the King
Moderator
Princess Dot
 
Posts: 2607
Joined: Sep 22, 2009
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby waggawerewolf27 » Mar 12, 2010 2:38 am

That take on which book is scariest is fair enough. But then there is something about 'Silver Chair' which is compelling.

Dr Elwin Ransom wrote:But what we don't like to think about as often is what exactly a hero is saving us from.


I saw this quote from another thread in this forum and wondered just how applicable it might be to 'Silver Chair'. On the whole, I think it is, more so than any of the other books. I know that in LWW Edmund betrayed his siblings out of a longing to be the only person in the family to be the main one. I know that in PC it was Peter who failed to ask Aslan for direction. And I know that in VDT it was Eustace who had to be undragoned.

But 'Silver Chair' is the book in which LOTGK might well be the main enemy, but it is Eustace and Jill who are very often their own worst enemies.

Take the bullying at the beginning. Eustace had gone along with it until he returned from his trip to Aslan's World. Jill doesn't know any alternative to the bullying at that stage. Then there is the cliff. Eustace and Jill have different phobias, likes and dislikes. And so they get off to a bad start for their quest, because of Jill's 'showing off'.

This story is really Puddleglum's. Without him, Eustace and Jill would have been stumped, lost, and even eaten long beforehand. Until they all reach the palace of LOTGK, none of the travellers are actually forced to do anything.other than accompany the Bism gnomes. And even then it is all persuasion, drugs, incense and hypnotism which the LOTGK uses to gull Eustace, Jill and Rilian to agree with herself.

One of the most scary parts of 'Silver Chair' is the trio's experiences being captive in Harfang. But then nobody told them to go to Harfang, where they very nearly form part of the menu for the Autumn feast. They never saw the armoured knight as a person, and the advice LOTGK gave the travellers was merely advice, nothing more. I put it to you, oh learned fellow NarniaWebbers, that it was only Eustace and Jill's own weaknesses that caused them to go to Harfang, being hungry, cold and tired, normal conditions for much of humanity. There was no fantastic enchantment from the Emerald Witch to coerce them in any way.

So are we being urged to be wary of ourselves and our own desires, in the Silver Chair?
User avatar
waggawerewolf27
NarniaWeb Zealot
 
Posts: 8781
Joined: Sep 25, 2009
Location: Oz
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Pepper Darcy » Jun 28, 2010 10:08 am

A very good point. I love those lines of Puddleglum. And it's one reason The Silver Chair (and VotDT as well) is my favourite book of the Chronicles. It's the learning to follow Aslan (for us, Christ) no matter what anyone else tells you, no matter what anyone else says, thinks, or does. No matter what the culture tells you. Jill, Eustace, and Puddleglum had the signs to follow; we have God's Word. We *can* know, and we must follow even if to the World what we believe is just a child's 'playworld' (acording to the Witch in SC)

Puddleglum *may* have been a wetblanket, but his heart was in the right place. He was loyal and unfailing to Aslan! So should we be as well.
Image

:music: risk it all cuz I'll catch you if you fall... if my heart was a house you'd be home :music:
User avatar
Pepper Darcy
NarniaWeb Nut
 
Posts: 161
Joined: Sep 23, 2009
Location: Lalineth
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Mustardseed19 » May 12, 2011 11:48 am

daughter of the King wrote:But isn't faith simple? We are to believe like a little child. Puddleglum here is showing the simplicity of his faith. He believes in Aslan, so he's going to follow him. And no witch by any means is going to take him off that path.


There's nothing simple about faith. To have great faith you have to go through a lot of hardships and trials, which test your faith. It's very easy, simple even, to say you have faith in God but never have to put it to a real test. Look at Paul. There was nothing simple about his faith. He learned to trust in God by the things he experienced. He even said that he 'learned' to be content in all circumstances. Same with Job. I think Puddleglum declaration is more akin to Job's when he said: 'Though he slay me, yet will I hope in him.' Puddleglum has just been through a trial, he's experienced doubts along the way, but he's learned something, and his determination to follow Aslan proves it. His faith may seem simple, but it's not. It's been tested and proven to be gold.
Mustardseed19
NarniaWeb Newbie
 
Posts: 1
Joined: May 12, 2011

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby juzuma loves lucy » Jun 07, 2011 7:38 am

"If there isn't any Aslan". Isn't Aslan compared to Christ? It explains all. Sometimes people doesn't believe in God, but... We believe in God even if there isn't any God. So it's the deep of SC. Puddleglum bravely shows all how to be the true Christian. That's all. There is also one thing... but you must find it yourselves.
juzuma loves lucy
NarniaWeb Nut
 
Posts: 101
Joined: Jun 04, 2011
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby narnialuver » Nov 06, 2011 11:17 am

Liberty Hoffman wrote:SC has the theme of following Aslan throughout the book. Jill has to learn the signs, but when she gets distracted, she forgets and it gets them in trouble! just like us! we have the Bible to show us the way, but if we foret what it says or don't follow it, then we get in trouble.


you are so right. the sighs represent the bible when we forget the bible we are lost!
Image

The Hobbit in theaters: 14 December 2012
User avatar
narnialuver
NarniaWeb Nut
 
Posts: 113
Joined: Nov 05, 2011
Location: Narnia
Gender: Male

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Lilygloves » Nov 21, 2011 6:55 pm

Going back to the famous quote "I'm going to live as like a Narnian as I can even if there isn't any Narnia!", which I believe is one of the most famous quotes in the whole Narnia series among fans, I can totally relate that to my Christian walk. It reminds me of another C.S. Lewis quote, "Christianity, if false, is of no importance, and if true, of infinite importance. The only thing it cannot be is moderately important." It makes me think of how important it is to have a strong faith even if others say it does not matter. I'm going to live as like a Christian as I can even if there isn't any Christ!"
User avatar
Lilygloves
NarniaWeb Junkie
 
Posts: 573
Joined: Dec 18, 2010
Location: A diner
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Melda Laure » Nov 21, 2011 10:47 pm

Puddleglum's statement is unacceptable as a declaration of faith; you cant have faith in something you KNOW to be untrue (which is why reason is such a stumbling block to those without adequate wisdom to question the limits of their "knowledge") .

But as the statement of someone teetering between despair and delirium, as a last act of defiance - a declaration of irrational faith in the face of defeat, that is worthy IN THAT CONTEXT.

Ok... the scene I find most memorable...

"Shall I be deprived of my son AND my most trusted friend in one day?"


The one thing that sticks in my mind is when Lewis telling about the Disappearance of Rillian, and Drinian comes to confess what he knows about the LOTGK to King Caspian. Caspian, in a mad rage, flies at Drinian with battle axe to hew him head to foot -

and Drinian just stands there.

And then at the last instant realizing what he is about to do, Caspian halts and drops the weapon and embraces him. And they both burst into tears.

THAT is forgivness, and redemption and mortification, and sorrow and loss all at once! Intensified ninefold because unblinded by rage nothing hides the abyss of tears and pain of shared loss.

Ah, "tales filled with the sadness of men". I guess when you're 12 years old the scene sort of passes by. But after you've been through the meat grinder... Eh? Bah! I'm over that.
“The Edge... there is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over.” ~ H. Thompson... Unless the road to paradise is a waterfall flowing straight up.
User avatar
Melda Laure
NarniaWeb Newbie
 
Posts: 5
Joined: Nov 11, 2011

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Varnafinde » Jul 19, 2012 6:41 pm

Melda Laure wrote:But as the statement of someone teetering between despair and delirium, as a last act of defiance - a declaration of irrational faith in the face of defeat, that is worthy IN THAT CONTEXT.


That's a good description of what that statement really is. Puddleglum is free of the enchantment, and he has provoked the Green Witch enough to have her set aside her sweet words and become really angry - there's no knowing what she will do next. In that situation he defies her with a bold statement.

Melda Laure wrote:THAT is forgivness, and redemption and mortification, and sorrow and loss all at once! Intensified ninefold because unblinded by rage nothing hides the abyss of tears and pain of shared loss.


That is indeed a great scene, and a great picture of forgiveness! "Their friendship was not broken" - Caspian was able to see past all that had happened and to see the value of keeping what was still left to him. A beautiful moment.

I also see as a theme - a minor theme, perhaps - the almost greed that Jill and Eustace feel for getting hot food and warm beds while they are walking through the snow before they reach Harfang, and especially as they are crossing what is later shown to be the Ruined City. Their hurry to reach the Giant's house makes them unwilling to listen to reason when Puddleglum tries to have them stop and think.

Greed as a temptation, perhaps?

They really needed nourishment, of course, but the Green Witch had put an idea into their heads that drove out all other considerations.
Image
(avi artwork by Henning Janssen)
User avatar
Varnafinde
Moderator
Princess of the Noldor and Royal Overseer of the Talk About Narnia forum
 
Posts: 2377
Joined: Jul 13, 2005
Location: Western Wild
Gender: Female

Re: Christian Themes in the Silver Chair

Postby Narnian_Badger » Jul 19, 2012 7:37 pm

narnian1 wrote:I love how Puddleglum over comes his pessimistic mind and confirms that exist or not he will follow Aslan and be a true narnian, and that I think should characterize all christians, (not the pessimistic of Puddleglum but his firm belief in Aslan, in our case God).

I had a lot of trouble with Puddleglum's quote for a while--felt too close to the idea that one should believe in God just because it's a safe bet (I believe that train of thought was especially popular in the Middle Ages...). Eventually, though, I realized that the quote is arranged like that not in spite of Puddleglum's pessimism, but because of it. As I've said on many occasions, Puddleglum is the eternal Optimist, wrapped up safely under several layers of pessimism. In a way, I'm kind of like him--a strong tendency to spout doom, gloom, and a healthy dosage of snark, but absolutely refusing to let myself or anyone else give up until the very end.

Ahem. Puddleglum, especially in his drugged state, is always going to choose to talk about the absolute worst case scenario--it's who he is, and apparently runs in the Marshwiggle genes. Even though his mind is muddled and his spirits low, he is refusing to bow to the LotGK's lies--he knows something's up, but can't put his webbed finger on it. That's where Puddleglum's strength lies. His faith in Aslan is unshakable, even when the world is falling apart around him. He knows that Aslan is real somewhere, even if he can't imagine it being here with him.

That's the sort of faith we need to have in God--that even in our darkest hour, when everything closes in on us and we can't see how God could possibly be near, we have to rely on Him even still--even if it's only to believe that He is somewhere, with faith even "as small as a mustard seed." ;)
User avatar
Narnian_Badger
NarniaWeb Guru
 
Posts: 1152
Joined: May 21, 2008
Location: The Dawn Treader
Gender: Female

Previous

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests